What they say about Gnosticism: Difference between revisions
From 2nd Book
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (13 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
from: https://www.biblewise.com/bible_study/characters/first-century.php | from: https://www.biblewise.com/bible_study/characters/first-century.php | ||
The article is analyzed to demonstrate subtle hostilities. | |||
{{th}} | {{th}} | ||
{{ | {{2c| '''Article''' | '''Comment''' }} | ||
{{1c| Like Christianity, Gnosticism evolved over time. <ref>Hostility</ref>}} | {{2c| Gnosticism comes from the Greek word gnosis, meaning “knowledge.” · |The foundation is being laid for the disassociation of knowledge and faith. <ref>See [[Loyola]]</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Like Christianity, Gnosticism evolved over time. <ref>[[Hostility - Guilt by association]]</ref>}} | |||
{{1c| There were many forms of Gnosticism throughout early Christianity.}} | {{1c| There were many forms of Gnosticism throughout early Christianity.}} | ||
{{1c| Scholars have identified many strands prevalent in the first century that were synthesized within Gnosticism, including Egyptian religion, Judaism, Christianity, astrology, and Greek philosophy.}} | {{1c| Scholars have identified many strands prevalent in the first century that were synthesized within Gnosticism, including Egyptian religion, Judaism, Christianity, astrology, and Greek philosophy. <ref>[[Hostility - Guilt by association]]</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| An initial wave of Gnosticism arose after the destruction of the temple in 70CE, but it wasn’t until the second century that it gained in prominence and achieved its classical form. | {{1c| An initial wave of Gnosticism arose after the destruction of the temple in 70CE, but it wasn’t until the second century that it gained in prominence and achieved its classical form.<ref>Gnosticism - Simon Magus]]</ref>}} | ||
}} | {{1c| Early Gnosticism probably arose out of apocalyptic Judaism, and hostility towards the God of the Old Testament. <ref>[[Gnosticism - Simon Magus]] miracles were [[Gnosticism - magic power|magic power]].</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Early Gnosticism probably arose out of apocalyptic Judaism, and hostility towards the God of the Old Testament. <ref>Simon Magus | {{1c| It arose after people abandoned the idea that God would take action on their behalf.}} <ref>[[Gnosticism - magic power|magic power]]</ref> | ||
}} | {{1c| Gnostics believed that matter was evil and spirit was good. <ref> {{bgw| Ge 1:31 }} And God saw every thing that he had made, and, behold, [it was] very good. And the evening and the morning were the sixth day. [{And the evening … : Heb. And the evening was, and the morning was etc. }]</ref>}} {{bgw| Ro 8:7 }} Because the carnal mind [is] enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. [{the carnal … : Gr. the minding of the flesh }]</ref> | ||
{{1c| It arose after people abandoned the idea that God would take action on their behalf.}} | {{1c| This world and this body are not the ultimate reality. {{bgw| 1Ch 29:15 }} For we [are] strangers before thee, and sojourners, as [were] all our fathers: our days on the earth [are] as a shadow, and [there is] none abiding. [{abiding: Heb. expectation }]</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Gnostics believed that matter was evil and spirit was good.}} | {{1c| Matter was eternal and the world had been created out of this evil stuff. <ref>{{bgw| Ge 1:1 }} In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| This world and this body are not the ultimate reality.}} | {{1c| In other words, Gnostics believed that creation came out of evil matter. <ref>{{bgw|Ge 1:31 }} And God saw every thing that he had made, and, behold, [it was] very good. And the evening and the morning were the sixth day. [{And the evening … : Heb. And the evening was, and the morning was etc. }]</ref> }} | ||
{{1c| Matter was eternal and the world had been created out of this evil stuff.}} | {{1c| Since God was spirit and good, he could not have created matter. <ref>{{bgw| Ro 1:21 }} Because that, when they knew God, they glorified [him] not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| In other words, Gnostics believed that creation came out of evil matter.}} | {{1c| God created “spiritual elements” that handled matter and created the world. <ref>Cabbalists assign this to the letters.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Since God was spirit and good, he could not have created matter.}} | {{1c| As these “spiritual elements” drifted farther and farther from God, they became more and more ignorant of Him and, in the end, hostile to him. <ref>This is the foundation for them why man is and must be, hostile to God.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| God created “spiritual elements” that handled matter and created the world.}} | {{1c| Nonetheless, these spiritual elements had to be pacified (worshiped) because ultimately they were in control of the world, including all the people in it. <ref>or conquered... </ref>}} | ||
{{1c| As these “spiritual elements” drifted farther and farther from God, they became more and more ignorant of Him and, in the end, hostile to him.}} | {{1c| It led to a false humility of not being worthy and hence, not being able to approach God. <ref>Gnosticism drives the flesh.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Nonetheless, these spiritual elements had to be pacified (worshiped) because ultimately they were in control of the world, including all the people in it.}} | {{1c| Therefore, one needed to submit to the angels and “spiritual elements.” <ref>Source of praying to Mary and the dead</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| It led to a false humility of not being worthy and hence, not being able to approach God.}} | {{1c| In essence, then, the Gnostics believed that a spiritual God did not create the world. <ref>Denial that He is the creator, source of "The problem of evil"</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Therefore, one needed to submit to the angels and “spiritual elements.”}} | {{1c| In Gnostic thought, Jesus was one of those “spiritual elements” that God created, although he was certainly above all of them. <ref>Denial of the flesh of Christ. Foundation for denying the kenosis.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| In essence, then, the Gnostics believed that a spiritual God did not create the world.}} | {{1c| Since matter derived from evil, it stands to reason the body was also evil. <ref>THe carnal mind is enmity, not the carnal flesh. </ref>}} | ||
{{1c| In Gnostic thought, Jesus was one of those “spiritual elements” that God created, although he was certainly above all of them.}} | {{1c| Jesus, then, who was derived from God was spiritual. <ref>Denial of kenosis</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Since matter derived from evil, it stands to reason the body was also evil.}} | {{1c| He was not a real man (it has been said by Gnostics that when Jesus walked, he left no footprints). <ref> Magic Jesus</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Jesus, then, who was derived from God was spiritual.}} | {{1c| In Gnostic thought, a “redeemer” would descend from heaven, teach gnosis, and then return to heaven.<ref>Same as Jewish Adam Kadmon</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| He was not a real man (it has been said by Gnostics that when Jesus walked, he left no footprints).}} | |||
{{1c| In Gnostic thought, a “redeemer” would descend from heaven, teach gnosis, and then return to heaven.}} | |||
{{1c| Even though Gnostic thought predated Christ, it was adapted to include him.}} | {{1c| Even though Gnostic thought predated Christ, it was adapted to include him.}} | ||
{{1c| It led to the argument that only through gnosis could people understand and participate in the fulness of Christianity.}} | {{1c| It led to the argument that only through gnosis could people understand and participate in the fulness of Christianity. <ref>A perversion of "Only through teaching" can one know" {{bgw| Ro 10:17 }} So then faith [cometh] by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| In order for people to be saved, they had to find their way back to God.}} | {{1c| In order for people to be saved, they had to find their way back to God. <ref>Denial that God had chosen us</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| This “way” was barred by all those “spiritual elements.”}} | {{1c| This “way” was barred by all those “spiritual elements. <ref>The false teachers barred the way: {{bgw| Mt 23:13 }} But woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye shut up the kingdom of heaven against men: for ye neither go in [yourselves], neither suffer ye them that are entering to go in.</ref>”}} | ||
{{1c| In order for the soul to get to God, it had to bypass these elements, one by one.}} | {{1c| In order for the soul to get to God, it had to bypass these elements, one by one. <ref>Source for casting out demons from Christians</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| The only way to pass by them was to have secret passwords or special knowledge.}} | {{1c| The only way to pass by them was to have secret passwords or special knowledge. <ref>Source for casting out demons from Christians using exorcism rituals</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Gnosticism was able to provide this secret knowledge.}} | {{1c| Gnosticism was able to provide this secret knowledge.}} | ||
{{1c| Such knowledge came through doctrinal instruction, ritual, prophecy, sacramental initiations, and self-discovery.}} | {{1c| Such knowledge came through doctrinal instruction, ritual, prophecy, sacramental initiations, and self-discovery.}} | ||
{{1c| This knowledge could be taught but generally came as a “call.”}} | {{1c| This knowledge could be taught but generally came as a “call.”}} | ||
{{1c| All this really meant was that salvation was based on knowledge. (There was nothing about forgiveness of sins, love for others, or the cross and resurrection in this theology.)}} | {{1c| All this really meant was that salvation was based on knowledge. (There was nothing about forgiveness of sins, love for others, or the cross and resurrection in this theology.)<ref>How many churches require confession of their 'distinctive' doctrines to be saved?</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Nor was every person going to be able to achieve this level of knowledge.}} | {{1c| Nor was every person going to be able to achieve this level of knowledge. <ref>Only the elect? Calvinism?</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Only those who were spiritually minded could be saved.}} | {{1c| Only those who were spiritually minded could be saved.}} | ||
{{1c| The ordinary person, the earthly person was simply out of luck.}} | {{1c| The ordinary person, the earthly person was simply out of luck.}} | ||
{{1c| Because Gnostics saw matter as evil, many of them were rigidly ascetic.}} | {{1c| Because Gnostics saw matter as evil, many of them were rigidly ascetic.<ref>Monks</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| They tried to move away from matter and material things.}} | {{1c| They tried to move away from matter and material things.<ref> Monks</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Bodily pleasures were to be avoided.}} | {{1c| Bodily pleasures were to be avoided.<ref> Monks and priests</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Others, however, moved in the opposite direction of libertinism.}} | {{1c| Others, however, moved in the opposite direction of libertinism. <ref> Age of grace</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| The thought was that since the body was already evil, what did it matter what one did or how one lived?}} | {{1c| The thought was that since the body was already evil, what did it matter what one did or how one lived?}} | ||
{{1c| Their motto was “anything goes.”}} | {{1c| Their motto was “anything goes.”}} | ||
{{1c| Either way, they renounced their bodies and were “reborn.”}} | {{1c| Either way, they renounced their bodies and were “reborn.”}} | ||
{{1c| Gnostics believed themselves to be part of a privileged few.}} | {{1c| Gnostics believed themselves to be part of a privileged few. <ref> The elect</ref>}} | ||
{{1c| Christianity would wrestle with Gnosticism for centuries.}} | {{1c| Christianity would wrestle with Gnosticism for centuries. <ref> and still does.</ref>}} | ||
|} | |} | ||
Latest revision as of 03:53, 5 October 2022
What they say about Gnosticism [∞]
from: https://www.biblewise.com/bible_study/characters/first-century.php
The article is analyzed to demonstrate subtle hostilities.
| Article | Comment | |
| Gnosticism comes from the Greek word gnosis, meaning “knowledge.” · | The foundation is being laid for the disassociation of knowledge and faith. [1] | |
| Like Christianity, Gnosticism evolved over time. [1] | ||
| There were many forms of Gnosticism throughout early Christianity. | ||
| Scholars have identified many strands prevalent in the first century that were synthesized within Gnosticism, including Egyptian religion, Judaism, Christianity, astrology, and Greek philosophy. [1] | ||
| An initial wave of Gnosticism arose after the destruction of the temple in 70CE, but it wasn’t until the second century that it gained in prominence and achieved its classical form.[1] |
| |
| Early Gnosticism probably arose out of apocalyptic Judaism, and hostility towards the God of the Old Testament. [1] |
| |
| It arose after people abandoned the idea that God would take action on their behalf. | ||
| Gnostics believed that matter was evil and spirit was good. [2] | ||
| This world and this body are not the ultimate reality. ▸ ± 1Ch 29:15 For we [are] strangers before thee, and sojourners, as [were] all our fathers: our days on the earth [are] as a shadow, and [there is] none abiding. [{abiding: Heb. expectation }]</ref> | ||
| Matter was eternal and the world had been created out of this evil stuff. [1] | ||
| In other words, Gnostics believed that creation came out of evil matter. [1] | ||
| Since God was spirit and good, he could not have created matter. [1] | ||
| God created “spiritual elements” that handled matter and created the world. [1] |
| |
| As these “spiritual elements” drifted farther and farther from God, they became more and more ignorant of Him and, in the end, hostile to him. [1] |
| |
| Nonetheless, these spiritual elements had to be pacified (worshiped) because ultimately they were in control of the world, including all the people in it. [1] |
| |
| It led to a false humility of not being worthy and hence, not being able to approach God. [1] |
| |
| Therefore, one needed to submit to the angels and “spiritual elements.” [1] |
| |
| In essence, then, the Gnostics believed that a spiritual God did not create the world. [1] |
| |
| In Gnostic thought, Jesus was one of those “spiritual elements” that God created, although he was certainly above all of them. [1] |
| |
| Since matter derived from evil, it stands to reason the body was also evil. [1] |
| |
| Jesus, then, who was derived from God was spiritual. [1] |
| |
| He was not a real man (it has been said by Gnostics that when Jesus walked, he left no footprints). [1] |
| |
| In Gnostic thought, a “redeemer” would descend from heaven, teach gnosis, and then return to heaven.[1] |
| |
| Even though Gnostic thought predated Christ, it was adapted to include him. | ||
| It led to the argument that only through gnosis could people understand and participate in the fulness of Christianity. [1] | ||
| In order for people to be saved, they had to find their way back to God. [1] |
| |
| This “way” was barred by all those “spiritual elements. [1]” | ||
| In order for the soul to get to God, it had to bypass these elements, one by one. [1] |
| |
| The only way to pass by them was to have secret passwords or special knowledge. [1] |
| |
| Gnosticism was able to provide this secret knowledge. | ||
| Such knowledge came through doctrinal instruction, ritual, prophecy, sacramental initiations, and self-discovery. | ||
| This knowledge could be taught but generally came as a “call.” | ||
| All this really meant was that salvation was based on knowledge. (There was nothing about forgiveness of sins, love for others, or the cross and resurrection in this theology.)[1] |
| |
| Nor was every person going to be able to achieve this level of knowledge. [1] |
| |
| Only those who were spiritually minded could be saved. | ||
| The ordinary person, the earthly person was simply out of luck. | ||
| Because Gnostics saw matter as evil, many of them were rigidly ascetic.[1] |
| |
| They tried to move away from matter and material things.[1] |
| |
| Bodily pleasures were to be avoided.[1] |
| |
| Others, however, moved in the opposite direction of libertinism. [1] |
| |
| The thought was that since the body was already evil, what did it matter what one did or how one lived? | ||
| Their motto was “anything goes.” | ||
| Either way, they renounced their bodies and were “reborn.” | ||
| Gnostics believed themselves to be part of a privileged few. [1] |
| |
| Christianity would wrestle with Gnosticism for centuries. [1] |
|
