John's Messianic Preaching: Difference between revisions

From 2nd Book
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
Tags: Reverted Visual edit
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
{{bgw| Mk 1.7-8 }} {{bgw| Mt 3.11-12 }} {{bgw| Lk 3.15-18}} {{bgw| Joh 1.24-28 }}
{{bgw| Mk 1.7-8 }} {{bgw| Mt 3.11-12 }} {{bgw| Lk 3.15-18}} {{bgw| Joh 1.24-28 }}


7 And this was his message: “After me comes the one more powerful than I, the straps of whose sandals I am not worthy to stoop down and untie. 8 I baptize you with[a] water, but he will baptize you with[b] the Holy Spirit.”
=== '''Comparison of the Gospel Accounts: John the Baptist’s Message''' ===
(Mark 1:7-8, Matthew 3:11-12, Luke 3:15-18, John 1:24-28)
----


11 “I baptize you with[a] water for repentance. But after me comes one who is more powerful than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with[b] the Holy Spirit and fire. 12 His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor, gathering his wheat into the barn and burning up the chaff with unquenchable fire.”
== '''1. Common Elements Across the Accounts''' ==


* '''John the Baptist speaks of one coming after him.'''
* '''John contrasts his baptism with Jesus’ baptism.'''
** John baptizes with '''water'''.
** Jesus will baptize with '''the Holy Spirit''' (all accounts) and '''fire''' (Matthew and Luke).
* '''John expresses his unworthiness in relation to Jesus.'''
** He is '''unworthy to untie/loosen His sandal''' (Mark, Luke, John).
* '''Jesus brings judgment and separation.'''
** The '''winnowing fork''' imagery (Matthew and Luke).


----


15''' The people were waiting expectantly and were all wondering in their hearts if John might possibly be the Messiah.''' 16 John answered them all, “I baptize you with[a] water. But one who is more powerful than I will come, the straps of whose sandals I am not worthy to untie. He will baptize you with[b] the Holy Spirit and fire. 17 His winnowing fork is in his hand to clear his threshing floor and to gather the wheat into his barn, but he will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire.18''' And with many other words John exhorted the people and proclaimed the good news to them.'''
== '''2. Differences Between the Accounts''' ==
{| class="wikitable"
!'''Gospel'''
!'''Key Differences'''
|-
|'''Mark 1:7-8'''
|Shortest account. Only mentions Spirit baptism, omits fire/judgment.
|-
|'''Matthew 3:11-12'''
|Adds '''fire''' with Spirit baptism. Includes '''winnowing fork/chaff''' judgment imagery.
|-
|'''Luke 3:15-18'''
|Similar to Matthew but '''adds people's speculation''' about John being the Messiah. Calls John's preaching '''"good news."'''
|-
|'''John 1:24-28'''
|Different focus—John the Baptist answers Pharisees about his identity. '''No mention of fire or judgment.''' Instead, John emphasizes Jesus' '''preexistence.'''
|}
----


== '''3. How Does the Study During the Gaps of Authorship Explain the Differences?''' ==
Since '''Mark was written first''', Matthew, Luke, and John expanded on his simpler account based on further '''study of the Old Testament and reflection on Christ’s fulfillment.'''


* '''Matthew adds the "fire" aspect''', possibly recognizing its '''judgment/purification''' meaning from the OT.
* '''Luke expands on the people's reaction, adding speculation about John being the Messiah''', suggesting a later reflection on how people misunderstood John's role.
* '''John takes a theological direction, focusing on preexistence rather than judgment.''' This reflects deeper contemplation on '''Genesis themes of creation and preexistence.'''


24 '''Now the Pharisees who had been sent 25 questioned him, “Why then do you baptize if you are not the Messiah, nor Elijah, nor the Prophet?”'''
'''Pattern of Expansion:'''


26 “I baptize with[a] water,” John replied, “but among you stands one you do not know. 27 He is the one who comes after me, the straps of whose sandals I am not worthy to untie.
# '''Mark''' – Simple statement.
# '''Matthew''' – Adds '''fire and judgment''' imagery.
# '''Luke''' – Adds '''historical context and crowd reactions.'''
# '''John''' – Focuses on '''Jesus' eternal nature rather than the event itself.'''


28 This all happened at Bethany on the other side of the Jordan, where John was baptizing.The expectation of the Messiah during the time of John the Baptist was fueled by a combination of scriptural prophecies, historical circumstances, and societal tensions. Here are some key reasons:
----


=== 1. '''Prophetic Timelines''' ===
== '''4. Unique Ideas of Each Gospel Author''' ==


* '''Daniel's Seventy Weeks Prophecy (Daniel 9:24-27):''' Many Jewish scholars interpreted this prophecy as indicating the approximate time of the Messiah's arrival. By the time of John the Baptist, the 69 "weeks" (interpreted as symbolic years) were thought to be nearing completion, pointing to the imminent appearance of the Anointed One.
=== '''Mark (First Account, Basic Structure)''' ===


=== 2. '''Roman Occupation''' ===
* Emphasizes '''Jesus' superiority''' over John.
* '''No fire or judgment''', just '''Spirit baptism'''—perhaps leaving room for future revelation.


* The Roman rule over Israel created a strong longing for deliverance. The Jewish people were living under oppressive foreign rule, and many believed that the Messiah would come as a political or military leader to liberate them and restore the Davidic kingdom.
=== '''Matthew (Focus on Judgment and Fulfillment)''' ===


=== 3. '''Heightened Messianic Expectations''' ===
* Adds '''"fire"''' to Spirit baptism, suggesting '''judgment or purification.'''
* Uses '''winnowing fork imagery''' (separation of wheat and chaff).
* Emphasizes '''imminent judgment''', fitting Matthew’s theme of '''Jesus as the fulfillment of prophecy'''.


* During the Second Temple period, messianic fervor was already high due to various apocalyptic writings and movements. Groups like the Essenes, who wrote the Dead Sea Scrolls, were actively anticipating the Messiah and preparing for His arrival.
=== '''Luke (Focus on the People's Response)''' ===
* Many believed in the coming of a prophet like Elijah, based on '''Malachi 4:5-6''', which foretold the return of Elijah before the "great and terrible day of the Lord."


=== 4. '''John the Baptist’s Ministry''' ===
* Adds '''the crowd's speculation''' about whether John is the Messiah.
* Also includes '''fire and judgment''', like Matthew.
* '''Calls John's message "good news"'''—unique to Luke.


* John the Baptist’s role as a prophet and his call for repentance added to the anticipation. His bold message and practice of baptizing people in the Jordan River evoked imagery of a new beginning for Israel, similar to the crossing of the Jordan under Joshua.
=== '''John (Focus on Christ’s Preexistence)''' ===
* John identified himself as "the voice of one crying in the wilderness" (Isaiah 40:3), further aligning himself with messianic expectations and signaling that the Messiah was near.


=== 5. '''Scriptural Promises''' ===
* '''No mention of fire or judgment.'''
* Highlights '''John’s testimony about Jesus being before him''', tying to John’s theme of Jesus as the '''Word from the beginning (John 1:1-3).'''
* '''Focuses on John's interaction with the Pharisees''' rather than the crowds.


* Key Messianic prophecies like Isaiah 7:14 (the virgin birth), Isaiah 9:6-7 (a child born who will reign on David’s throne), and Micah 5:2 (Messiah’s birth in Bethlehem) were well known to the Jewish people. These scriptures created a backdrop of hope and longing for the arrival of the promised Savior.
----


=== 6. '''Historical Precedents''' ===
== '''5. OT Scripture That May Have Reminded Matthew of This Event''' ==
Since '''Matthew emphasizes judgment and purification''', he may have been reminded of:


* The Maccabean Revolt (167–160 BCE) had stirred messianic hopes in the past, as it temporarily liberated Israel from foreign rule. However, the eventual re-subjugation under Rome reignited the desire for a true and lasting deliverer.
=== '''1. Malachi 3:1-3 (The Messenger and Refining Fire)''' ===
''"Behold, I send my messenger, and he will prepare the way before me... He will sit as a refiner and purifier of silver."''


=== 7. '''Signs of the Times''' ===
🔹 '''Connection:''' John sees '''fire as purification and judgment''', just like Malachi.


* Many believed they were living in a spiritually and morally decadent age, one ripe for divine intervention. The appearance of a prophet like John the Baptist, after centuries without prophetic voices, was seen as a sign that God was about to act.
=== '''2. Isaiah 4:4 (Spirit and Fire for Cleansing)''' ===
''"When the Lord shall have washed away the filth of the daughters of Zion, and shall have purged the blood of Jerusalem by the spirit of judgment and by the spirit of burning."''


=== 1. '''The Role of John the Baptist as the Forerunner''' ===
🔹 '''Connection:''' The '''Spirit and fire''' are for '''purification''', like John's baptism message.


* John’s ministry as "the voice crying in the wilderness" (Isaiah 40:3) reflects a deeper symbolic pattern. In Sensus Plenior, the wilderness represents both a place of preparation and testing (e.g., Israel in the wilderness for 40 years, Christ’s 40 days in the wilderness). John's call to repentance can be seen as the spiritual equivalent of preparing a straight path for the Lord—removing obstacles (sin) for the coming of Christ.
=== '''3. Psalm 1:4 (Wicked Like Chaff in the Wind)''' ===
* His baptism in the Jordan River also mirrors Israel's crossing into the Promised Land, symbolizing a transition into the spiritual reality of the Kingdom of God, which Christ would inaugurate.
''"The wicked are like chaff that the wind drives away."''


=== 2. '''Timing in Light of Daniel’s Prophecy''' ===
🔹 '''Connection:''' Matches Matthew’s '''winnowing fork/chaff imagery'''.
----


* Daniel 9's prophecy of the seventy weeks can be seen through the lens of Christ's fulfillment. Sensus Plenior emphasizes that numbers, patterns, and timings in Scripture are not random but reveal Christ. The "weeks" of years culminate in Christ's ministry as the fulfillment of the Anointed One who would bring reconciliation and establish a new covenant.
== '''6. Genesis Scriptures That May Have Reminded Luke of This Event''' ==
* The prophecy also anticipates the cutting off of the Messiah (His crucifixion) and the ultimate establishment of His eternal Kingdom. From a Sensus Plenior perspective, the historical context at the time of John aligns perfectly with these hidden spiritual truths.
Since '''Luke includes the people's speculation and the Holy Spirit focus''', he may have been reminded of:


=== 3. '''Historical Longing and Scriptural Patterns''' ===
=== '''1. Genesis 1:2 (Spirit Over the Waters)''' ===
''"The Spirit of God was hovering over the waters."''


* The Roman oppression mirrors the Egyptian bondage before the Exodus, another pattern fulfilled in Christ. Just as Moses was raised up as a deliverer to lead God’s people out of slavery, Christ is the ultimate Deliverer who rescues humanity from sin and death. John the Baptist plays the role of a new "Elijah" (Malachi 4:5-6), preparing the way for the true and greater "Moses" to lead His people to freedom.
🔹 '''Connection:''' The '''Spirit over water''' could foreshadow '''baptism in Spirit and water.'''


=== 4. '''Symbols of Light and Darkness''' ===
=== '''2. Genesis 6-7 (Noah’s Flood – Water as Judgment)''' ===
''"I will bring a flood of waters upon the earth to destroy all flesh."''


* At the time of John, there was spiritual darkness in Israel, marked by corruption among religious leaders and the burden of Roman rule. From a Sensus Plenior perspective, darkness represents love (the hidden love of God for His people) waiting to be unveiled, while light represents holiness (God’s revealed nature). John’s proclamation of the coming light (John 1:7-9) symbolizes the unveiling of God’s love through Christ's holiness.
🔹 '''Connection:''' Just as the flood '''separated the righteous from the wicked''', John’s baptism prepares for '''separation by fire.'''


=== 5. '''The Old Testament Fulfilled in Christ''' ===
=== '''3. Genesis 11:1-9 (Tower of Babel – Spirit and Fire)''' ===
''"Come, let us go down and confuse their language."''


* Every major promise and prophecy in the Old Testament finds its deeper meaning in Christ:
🔹 '''Connection:''' Just as '''God "separates" people at Babel''', John's baptism and fire separate '''the righteous and unrighteous.'''
** '''Isaiah 7:14 (the virgin birth):''' This promise of "Immanuel" (God with us) speaks of God's intimate presence. At the time of John, the expectation of the Messiah ties to the deeper truth that the "seed of the woman" (Genesis 3:15) would come to crush the serpent's head.
** '''Micah 5:2 (birth in Bethlehem):''' Bethlehem ("house of bread") is a picture of Christ as the bread of life, who would be born in obscurity to bring spiritual sustenance to the world.
** '''Malachi 3:1:''' The messenger (John) prepares the way for the "Messenger of the Covenant" (Christ), fulfilling God's promise of sudden, transformative visitation.


=== 6. '''John as a Transition Between Old and New''' ===
=== '''4. Genesis 19:24 (Sodom – Fire from Heaven)''' ===
''"The Lord rained fire and brimstone on Sodom."''


* John represents the culmination of the Old Testament era, standing as the "greatest born of women" (Matthew 11:11) yet pointing to the One who transcends it. In Sensus Plenior, John’s role reflects the transition from the shadow of the Law to the reality of grace and truth in Christ. His message of repentance parallels the Law's purpose: to bring awareness of sin, making way for grace through Christ.
🔹 '''Connection:''' Luke’s '''fire imagery''' recalls '''judgment and separation''' in Sodom.
----


=== 7. '''The Temple and the Presence of God''' ===
== '''7. Your Unique Ideas in Putting This Together''' ==
🔹 '''1. Seeing the Evolution of John’s Message Across the Gospels'''


* At the time of John, the Second Temple stood, but God’s presence had not returned to it after the exile (Ezekiel 10). The Messiah’s arrival fulfills the deeper truth that God would no longer dwell in a physical temple but in His people. John's call to repentance prepares Israel for this radical shift—the true temple is Christ Himself, and through Him, believers become the dwelling place of God (1 Corinthians 3:16).
* Rather than a '''single static message''', John’s words were '''expanded as the Gospel authors gained new insights'''. They remembered better with new triggers as guided by the Spirit.
 
* The '''gaps in authorship allowed for deeper study and fuller understanding'''.
----


=== Summary in Sensus Plenior ===
🔹 '''2. Connecting Genesis More Deeply to the Event'''
From this perspective, the expectation of the Messiah at the time of John the Baptist was not merely historical or prophetic but also deeply symbolic of God’s eternal plan. Every event, prophecy, and pattern in the Old Testament finds its hidden meaning in Christ. The timing was perfect, not only because of external circumstances but because it aligned with the unveiling of these eternal truths: the love and holiness of God revealed in the person and work of Christ.


Would you like to explore how specific Old Testament symbols might further reinforce this expectation?
* Many focus on '''Isaiah or Malachi''', but your approach highlights '''Genesis as an overlooked source of inspiration.'''
* You connect:
** '''Genesis 1 (Spirit over waters) → Baptism'''
** '''Genesis 6-7 (Flood) → Judgment & Cleansing'''
** '''Genesis 19 (Sodom) → Fire Judgment'''
** '''Genesis 11 (Babel) → Spirit Separating'''


🔹 '''3. Fire as Purification Rather Than Just Judgment'''


=== '''Reasons They Might Remember''' ===
* Many view '''John’s “fire” as destruction''', but you emphasize it as '''purification''' (Malachi 3:3, Isaiah 4:4).
* This aligns with the idea that '''Jesus refines rather than simply condemns.'''


# '''The Massacre of Children (Matthew 2:16-18):'''
🔹 '''4. Luke’s Unique "Good News" Angle'''
#* Herod’s slaughter of the innocents in Bethlehem would have been a traumatic and unforgettable event. Those who survived or heard the story might have wondered if such a terrible act was tied to the coming of a significant figure, especially given the rumor that Herod feared a new "king of the Jews."
#* In Sensus Plenior terms, the massacre could be seen as a shadow of the enmity between the seed of the woman (Genesis 3:15) and the serpent, with Herod acting as a pawn of this spiritual conflict.
# '''Visitation of the Magi (Matthew 2:1-12):'''
#* The arrival of the Magi from the East and their inquiries about the "king of the Jews" may have stirred speculation. Their gifts—gold, frankincense, and myrrh—were highly symbolic, pointing to Christ's kingship, divinity, and sacrifice.
#* Although the Magi’s visit likely caused a stir in Jerusalem (Matthew 2:3), the memory of their visit might have faded for most, as it was not widely publicized beyond Herod’s court and Bethlehem.
# '''The Shepherds’ Witness (Luke 2:8-20):'''
#* The shepherds were told by angels that the Messiah had been born, and they spread the news. While their testimony likely sparked local excitement, it may have been dismissed by many as the ramblings of ordinary shepherds.
#* In Sensus Plenior, the shepherds represent the lowly and humble, the ones to whom God reveals His mysteries. Their role ties into the broader theme of Christ being revealed to the humble, not the proud.
# '''Prophecies at the Temple (Luke 2:25-38):'''
#* Simeon and Anna, two devout individuals, publicly recognized the infant Jesus as the Messiah when He was presented at the Temple. Their declarations were prophetic and powerful, but again, this moment might not have been widely remembered, as it occurred within the limited context of the Temple community.


----
* You could argue that '''Luke reinterprets fire as part of the "good news"'''—not just wrath, but the '''Spirit’s transforming power'''.


=== '''Reasons They Might Not Remember''' ===
🔹 '''5. John’s Gospel as a Reflection on Preexistence Rather Than Event'''


# '''Geographical and Temporal Distance:'''
* Instead of focusing on the '''baptism event''', John expands it to reflect '''on Jesus as eternal.'''
#* The events surrounding Jesus’ birth occurred primarily in and around Bethlehem and were not widely known in other parts of Judea or Galilee. By the time of John’s ministry, around 30 years had passed, and memories of those events would have faded.
* This could align with your insight that '''later Gospel authors gained theological clarity over time.'''
# '''Herod’s Secrecy:'''
#* Herod, in his paranoia, likely suppressed information about the massacre and the Magi's visit. The story of the "king of the Jews" might have been known in small circles but was unlikely to become widespread public knowledge.
# '''Jesus’ Lowly Status:'''
#* Jesus grew up in Nazareth, a small and seemingly insignificant town. Even Nathanael asked, "Can anything good come from Nazareth?" (John 1:46). People might not have connected the carpenter’s son with the dramatic events of three decades earlier.
# '''Cultural Amnesia and Political Distractions:'''
#* The Jewish people were under Roman rule and facing daily struggles, including political oppression and religious tension. These concerns likely overshadowed memories of past events that didn’t appear immediately relevant.


----
----


=== '''Sensus Plenior Insights''' ===
== '''Conclusion''' ==
Each Gospel writer '''built upon Mark’s foundation''', adding layers based on '''study, revelation, and audience needs.''' Your approach reveals:


* '''The Messiah Hidden in Plain Sight:'''
# '''Genesis as a primary OT trigger''' for Luke’s and John’s reflections.
** The fact that Jesus’ birth and its surrounding events didn’t lead to widespread recognition aligns with the biblical theme of God working in hidden and unexpected ways. Just as God’s love (darkness) was veiled in the Old Testament, Christ’s first coming was veiled in humility, visible only to those with spiritual eyes to see.
# '''Fire as purification''' rather than simple destruction.
** This parallels how the deeper truths of Scripture (Sensus Plenior) are hidden until revealed by the Spirit.
# '''Luke’s “good news” emphasis''' in contrast to Matthew’s judgment focus.
* '''The Foreshadowing of Rejection:'''
# '''John’s theological expansion into Jesus' preexistence.'''
** The lack of recognition of Jesus’ significance at His birth foreshadows His later rejection by the people. Even though His life fulfilled prophecies, His contemporaries failed to see the deeper meanings until after His death and resurrection.
 
----


=== '''Conclusion''' ===
[[GSG: {{PAGENAME}} ]]
While some people may have remembered the extraordinary events of Jesus’ birth, the majority likely did not connect them to the coming of the Messiah. The people’s anticipation at the time of John the Baptist was driven more by current events and prophetic teachings than by lingering memories of Jesus' early years. However, those with spiritual insight, like Simeon, Anna, and perhaps even John the Baptist, would have recognized how those events fit into God’s greater plan.

Navigation menu